South Africa’s real nutrition problems
Based on how much of our public space Tim Noakes and the Banting diet occupy, you might think that one of the most important nutrition problems facing South Africa is the carbohydrate vs fat intake in our diets. It just isn’t.
David Sanders is Emeritus Professor at the University of Western Cape’s School of Public Health. A paediatrician, for 30 years he has been explaining the links between politics, poverty and nutrition. He is outspoken on the steps that need to be taken to improve childhood nutrition, and a passionate advocate for breastfeeding. While not nearly as well known to the general public as Noakes, he is a leading figure in public and child health and respected by scientists in his field. He has published a long list of peer-reviewed papers as well as several books.
Sanders is not entirely opposed to Noakes’ diet for adults. He agrees that “the amount of refined carbohydrates in what has become the modern diet is excessive and dangerous.” He also says that research has shown that saturated fats are a lot less dangerous than previously thought but that the long term effects of a diet high in animal fat and protein have yet to be determined.
“But Noakes goes overboard in his extremely stringent recommendations about carbohydrate intake,” says Sanders. “It seems to be ahistorical and also infeasible for most people.”
Instead, Sanders points to the country’s high rates of low birth weight, malnutrition, obesity and disease, and how these occur in an environment where large food corporations have penetrated the market, offering food of questionable nutrition that is cheaper than healthy alternatives.
“Noakes goes overboard … his extremely stringent recommendations … seem to be … ahistorical and also infeasible for most people.”
The latest data from the South African National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey SANHANES indicates that 28% of South African households were at risk of hunger and 26% experienced hunger in 2012. Undernutrition among children is high, with the prevalence of stunting sitting at 27% of children under three. About 6% of children under 14 are underweight, about one in a hundred severely so.
On the other end of the scale, 19% of children aged between two to five were classified as overweight and 5% were classified as obese in 2012. At six to nine years these results dropped slightly but at ten to 14 years 17% of children in the survey were overweight and nearly 6% were obese.
Low birth weight is correlated with poor infant health. 15% of all live births have a low weight at public healthcare facilities according to the 2013 Saving Babies report. These low birth weights are associated with the majority of deaths within the first 28 days of life.
Sanders says that one of the main causes of low birth weight is suboptimal nutrition of the mother, especially before and during the early months of pregnancy. Hard physical labour as well as substance abuse in the form of tobacco, alcohol and drugs can also cause low birth weight. HIV and other sexually transmitted infections also contribute. All these factors can lead to preterm births as well as babies carried to full term but born at low weights.
A baby with a low birth weight may be unable to breastfeed properly and therefore can’t receive adequate nutrition. He or she is also more susceptible to infections and has a greater tendency to become undernourished as a young child.
“There is increasing evidence that low birth weight infants, especially those who were small for gestational age, if exposed to an environment where nutrients are unlimited, have a greater tendency to early obesity, diabetes and heart disease,” says Sanders. “The idea is that because this foetus has been relatively starved in utero, it becomes very efficient at utilising all nutrients offered.”
Nutrition in South Africa
- About one in four people (26%) experienced hunger in 2012.
- More than one in four children under three have stunted growth.
- 1% of children are severely underweight. About 6% are underweight.
- 6% of children aged 10 to 14 are obese.
- 15% of live births are underweight.
According to Stats SA’s Mortality and Causes of Death 2013, the leading cause of death for children under five in 2013 was intestinal infectious diseases (which results in diarrhoea), followed by respiratory and cardiovascular disorders specific to the perinatal period (before and during birth). Third was influenza and pneumonia. Many of these deaths are attributable to HIV infection, but nutritional factors are also likely often the primary cause or a contributory one.
The first form of nutrition most babies receive upon birth is breastmilk. It contains all the nutrients needed for growth and it provides immunity to diseases. Sanders is a strong proponent of exclusive breastfeeding, which is nothing but breast milk for the first six months of life.
“We have the lowest breastfeeding rates in the world. The best data tell us that our exclusive breastfeeding rates at six months are 8%,” says Sanders. “One [reason for the purchase of formula milk] is that it is perceived as modern. Another is that the infant formula companies have had virtually a free hand in South Africa, although recently legislation has been introduced to regulate their operations.”
The International Code on the Marketing of Breastmilk Substitutes was compiled in 1981 but South Africa only translated the code into regulations in 2012. The regulations limit how formula milk can be marketed, and prevent it from being provided at clinics. Until recently, formula milk was provided to infants if the clinic deemed them undernourished.
Before studies showed that antiretroviral medicines could almost eliminate transmission of HIV to breastfeeding babies, South Africa’s HIV clinicians were divided on the role of formula milk (Sanders was outspoken against formula milk during this debate). Now there is consensus that exclusive breastfeeding coupled with antiretrovirals is the best option for HIV-positive mothers, and this is what guidelines recommend.
“Once you start to provide formula milk inside a health clinic you are sending a message that this is good,” says Sanders. He says that studies show that nearly all women who received free formula milk at South African clinics were actually mixed feeding – formula feeding in private and breastfeeding in public because formula feeding in poorer communities was seen as a sign of being HIV-positive.
Sanders explains that the dangers of mixed feeding are a higher risk of HIV transmission and that the protection against disease provided by breastfeeding is reduced. “So children were not only dying of HIV, [they were dying] of pneumonia and under-nutrition related problems. All of these can be significantly reduced by breastfeeding because breastfeeding protects from infection,” he says.
Once infants begin to be weaned off breastmilk, the average South African mother feeds their baby watered down maize meal, a low nutrient food that will fill up the baby’s stomach but not provide them with the necessary nutrients. Sanders says that high energy foods should be added to a weaning diet such as oils and peanut butter, as well as proteins such as sour milk, beans and lentils.
The explanation for why one will find an undernourished child in the same family as an obese mother can be linked to a diet that is nutrient poor and monotonous. “They are both existing on the same diet, but the mother can accommodate enough mealie pap in her stomach to give her enough calories,” Sanders says.
Despite this, the obese mother will likely have a high level of micronutrient deficiency, explains Sanders.
Sanders advocates subsidising healthy foods and increasing taxes on unhealthy ones.
Micronutrient deficiencies, such as iron deficiency are particularly problematic for women of reproductive age. In 2012, 23% of South African women of reproductive age were anaemic, according to the SANHANES data. Sanders also says that anaemia can increase the risk of a low birth weight baby.
Sanders argues that one of the major problems with nutrition in South Africa is the proliferation of food corporations that relentlessly market and sell unhealthy food. He says that transnational food corporations are targeting middle income countries such as South Africa. “We have got this poor population, a large percentage of whom receive cash child support grants and other cash, and the supermarkets are spreading,” he says.
“Not only do we have significantly higher number of people living in towns than other African countries, but even the rural areas are urbanised in the sense that very few people undertake significant agricultural activities. So people live in rural areas, they don’t produce much of their food, and they purchase food.”
The SANHANES study found that it is mostly females who shop for groceries and that the most important factor for women when purchasing food was the price. Health was a much smaller consideration for most shoppers, especially if it was a male doing the shopping.
Sanders wants government intervention to reduce the costs of healthy foods by subsidising them and increase the costs of unhealthy foods by taxing them. “We are in a serious situation both from undernutrition and obesity,” he says.
My worry when it comes to Tim Noaks' banting diet is that the marketing strategy he implemented worked in his favour because most south Africans know about his diet and some are already following.
He appeared on TV a couple of times and that reached out to many South Africans. Our public healthcare system must improve its health/nutrition education strategies. In the past there used to be lots of promotional material nicely branded with educational messages and that has stopped because of shrinking funds.
In my view, Government spends millions of allocated budget on Human Resource which at the end is not even efficient and this efficiency is not reinforced. The government can do with the current staff or even less.
Many African countries are not as resourced as South Africa but they achieve far more outcomes than us, why? What makes poorer countries and warzone countries achieve better than us?
This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.