“We are struggling” says Robertson Winery worker as strike enters 13th week

Latest company offer rejected as union demands R8,500 per month

| By
Photo of a house
Robertson Winery sales office in Robertson, Western Cape. Photo: Ashraf Hendricks

On Thursday, striking workers from Robertson Winery and surrounding farms marched to the company’s office. The workers have rejected the R400 pay increase offered by Robertson Winery’s management and are demanding a “living wage” of R8,500 per month.

The strike of about 200 Robertson Winery workers is in its 13th week.

CSAAWU representative Deneco Dube said three key demands were that the company sign a ‘peace clause’ undertaking not to victimise striking workers when they return to work, payment of the usual annual Christmas bonus, and backdated wage increases to May.

Dube said: “I think the company should be realistic and think of the future of both parties. As a union, we have managed to get back dignity for our people.”

HR Manager and Risk Officer at Robertson Winery Reinette Jordaan said that on 8 November negotiations came to an unexpected deadlock when the union “withdrew all agreements reached up to that point”.

“The company’s final offer was rejected outright”, Jordaan said.

“At that point, the CCMA withdrew from the proceedings, stating that they can no longer continue with a process where the union is not acting in good faith and that to continue would be a waste of taxpayers’ money.”

Photo of a man
Commercial, Stevedoring, Agricultural and Allied Workers Union representative Daneco Dube. Photo: Ashraf Hendricks

Workers struggling

A worker, who did not want to be named, told GroundUp: “I hope the strike comes to an end. I recently got married and my wife who is working on a grape farm is not taking it well.”

Another worker said some frustrated long-time workers had resigned and claimed their benefits.

​CSAAWU is appealing for donations to support the striking workers.

Dube said that the few workers who had returned to work had first liaised with the union and “we acknowledged their circumstances”. 

David Everson and his wife both work for the winery and they have two children aged 12 and 17 in school. They have had no income for three months. Their savings are finished. Their family members and friends are working on nearby farms and earn too little to help them.

Everson said: “We are struggling – borrowing, and friends giving us food here and there. We have also been receiving food hampers from CSAAWU, but the food is all used up.”

His main worry he says is people hounding him to settle his accounts. “I had to explain to my children that this year there is no Christmas goodies and clothes. They understand, hoping that we will get what we are fighting for.”

Sizwe Nxele said they were only asking for a living wage. He has four children. “The company is excelling and making a profit because of us … There is no peace at home. I am fighting all the time with the wife saying I should go back to work. But I refuse, saying my demands are not yet met,” he said.

A striking worker who did not wish to be named said that they are “mobilising other farm workers to join” the Commercial, Stevedoring, Agricultural and Allied Workers Union (CSAAWU). They are hoping that in January – grape harvesting time – union members will refuse to work for low wages.

“We hope other farmers will also increase their wages if they do not get enough people to pick grapes,” he said.

Racism allegation

A worker accused the management of racism. “Clocking [in and out] is done by blacks and coloureds only. We get wet when it’s raining, standing in the queue to clock in and out. When we take breaks we should clock in and out again. In winter, we should arrive early for clocking. Blacks start work at 7:30am and finish at 5:30pm; whites start at 8am and depart at 5pm … A black mechanic is paid R8,000 and a white mechanic paid R18,000.”

Jordaan replied to GroundUp that any employee remunerated per hour had to use the clocking system.

“It is untrue that a distinction is made between black and white workers. Production hours differ from admin hours. Admin employees work from 8am to 5pm and production employees from 7:30am to 5:15pm,” Jordaan stated.
TOPICS:  Farming Labour

Next:  Tafelberg study a breakthrough, say activists

Previous:  TAC pickets against alleged shoddy treatment at Khayelitsha clinic

Write a letter in response to this article


Dear Editor

The article states that the employer offered R400 increase but the union rejected it as it is demanding R8,500 a month.
We are left trying to compare apples and onions. It would be far more helpful to give us relevant numbers. What wage is the employer now offering? R8,400 a month, R3,400, R2,500? We are left in the dark as to the quantum of the dispute.

GroundUp Editor's Response

Apologies. Fair point. In an article published on 24 August, we wrote:

The workers, who protested outside the winery this morning, say they are currently earning between R2,900 and R3,500 a month before deductions, according to Karel Swart,  deputy general secretary of the Commercial, Stevedoring and Allied Workers' Union (CSAAWU).


Dear Editor

The article refers to the discrepancy between payment for white and black mechanics. Is this true? i think that when publishing valuable human rights information, you should refer to fact.

© 2016 GroundUp. Creative Commons License
This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

You may republish this article, so long as you credit the authors and GroundUp, and do not change the text. Please include a link back to the original article.