Refugees physically attack archbishop and Chris Nissen in Methodist church

Leadership justifies violence

| By and
Photo of Central Methodist Mission
A few hundred refugees have been occupying the Central Methodist Mission on Greenmarket Square. They are demanding to be resettled to a third country, i.e. not South Africa nor the countries they come from. Photo: Karabo Mafolo

On Friday morning, refugees staying in the Central Methodist Mission on Greenmarket Square in Cape Town physically attacked a delegation consisting of Archbishop Thabo Makgoba, Human Rights Commissioner Chris Nissen, a pastor and other members of civil society organisations.

Reverend Alan Storey from the Methodist Church says that he spoke to the people and told them they needed to vacate the church. “Chris Nissen (from the South African Human Rights Commission) explained which options are viable and which options weren’t viable.”

Storey says that when another man, name unknown, tried to speak, the refugees pushed forward and physically attacked the delegation. “We managed to get people to calm down. The leadership also called for calm and asked people to protect the delegation. But three people were seriously injured,” said Storey.

A widely circulated video backs up Storey’s version of events.

Reverend Annie Kirke, among those attacked, declined to comment.

Once there was calm, the delegation was able to leave the church.

One leader of the protest, Sylvie Nahimana, initially denied any violence, telling GroundUp: “We were told to leave the church. There was no violence.”

But after showing her the video, she said: “Every time we have meetings we always say we don’t want to speak to Adonis or Scalabrini, so it was the biggest mistake to come into this place and that’s why they got the beating of their life.”

“The man [who was assaulted] is coming from Scalabrini. Those are the businessmen always eating money in the name of helping refugees,” she said. “So we don’t want to see people like that in this place. You didn’t see the leaders beating them; it was the people because they know what kind of people they are. That’s why they beat them up.”

In fact, the Scalabrini Centre is a non-profit organisation that assists refugees. Nor were Scalabrini or Adonis part of the delegation that visited the mission on Friday.

Also, another source told GroundUp that the refugee leadership instigated the attack.

Amy Kaye who runs a crowdfunding campaign for the refugees said that the violence broke out because “they brought in people from organisations that the refugees expressly said that they did not want to work with”.

Meanwhile on Thursday, protestors living outside of the United Nations High Commission for Refugees (UNHCR) offices in Pretoria entered the offices through an open gate and took up shelter there.

A UNHCR statement read: “Some 150 foreign nationals, involved in a protest since 8 October outside UNHCR, the UN Refugee Agency’s office in Pretoria, South Africa, have forced their way into the compound this morning. The group may include refugees and asylum-seekers. The majority of our staff were safely evacuated out of the building.”

“UNHCR is engaged in a dialogue with the protestors, urging them to avoid any act of violence, vacate the premises and contribute to finding viable solutions. The latest development follows a Pretoria High Court order issued Wednesday 13 November, giving three days to foreign protestors to vacate all occupied public areas in the Waterkloof part of the city, where the UNHCR has its offices.”

News24 reported on Friday morning that police have begun removing the Pretoria demonstrators.

Mafolo is a Daily Maverick intern seconded to GroundUp.

TOPICS:  Immigration

Next:  PE street cleaners protest, demand backpay

Previous:  RDP houses torched after evictions in Fynbos

Write a letter in response to this article


Dear Editor

The violence and unruly behavior displayed by JP (one of the refugee leaders) and his group demonstrates how misrepresenting the truth can be disastrous. It has been 5 weeks and no sign of resettlement as promised when hundreds from the refugee community were mobilized.

The attack on the help, Give of the Givers, the attack on the Church leaders reflects how desperately JP and his group are willing to hold on to the false promises they have made. It is unfortunate that vulnerable refugees with genuine public safety and access to documentation issues are in a dilemma.

The danger with false promises and made up minds phenomena is that it usually leaves the architecture between the rock and a hard place. South Africa is not perfect but has accommodated the refugees for almost 18 years hence the level of entitlement. If they can demonstrate aggression to all the help provided then maybe they must just be left to continue believing in their lie. The sad reality is that children lost a year thereby cutting your nose to spite your face. I wonder how come other foreign nationals are still continuing working and staying in South Africa.

The violent aggression displayed is unacceptable and poses serious questions about calibre of leadership, credibility of issues and the real aim of refugee mobilisation, respect for the rule of law, arrogance and sheer distorting the truth for alterior motives. It also reflect on the extent of promises made to refugees and the conduct of desperate refugees who are expecting international community to assist them.

South Africa cannot resettle refugees to other countries. Africa should consider sorting its problems as migration needs to be addressed and if people do not have respect for the institutions in their own respective countries who will want to deal with unruly thugs who beat up people who do not agree with them. I still invite refugees to join local structures in fighting public safety as it threatens all our livelihoods and peace.

© 2019 GroundUp.
This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

You may republish this article, so long as you credit the authors and GroundUp, and do not change the text. Please include a link back to the original article.