Covid-19 testing is too expensive and too difficult in South Africa
Our current approach is probably costing lives
A rapid Covid antigen test with a negative result. Photo: Daniel Eriksson via Wikipedia (CC BY 4.0)
- South Africa is doing too few Covid tests.
- The price of a Covid antigen test is R350 at testing centres, but the wholesale price is about R130, and in other countries it’s much cheaper.
- Antigen tests, which give accurate enough results within 30 minutes, should be available at all pharmacies, and even for use in the home, the workplace and at school.
One of our staff members started coughing at work. She’s vaccinated and she also had Covid last year, but we decided not to take chances. So one of us took her to a drive-in Covid test centre run by a large pathology company at a private hospital in Cape Town.
We were the only client. We asked for an antigen test.
Covid antigen tests are accurate enough when someone has a high viral load. In contrast to PCR tests which take a day or two because they have to be done in a lab, antigen tests give a result within 30 minutes. They are excellent for detecting when someone with Covid is infectious.
Sorry, the nurse on duty told us, you can only get tested if you have a referral from a doctor. This is technically true according to National Institute of Communicable Diseases guidelines but one of us had previously been tested at the same facility without any referral.
This is an unimaginative, bureaucratic approach to Covid testing. South Africa has done about 18 million Covid tests. The UK, with only a slightly larger population, has done 320 million tests. Colombia, with a slightly smaller population, has done 26 million tests.
Last week South Africa averaged about 30,000 tests daily. In our best testing week, we averaged 70,000 a day. That’s far too little.
Testing is a vital part of the response to the pandemic. We can’t approximate the number of active cases without a lot more testing. With more testing, more infected people would know that they should isolate and they would infect fewer people.
The most important part of testing is picking up when people are infectious so that they can isolate and reduce the risk of infecting other people. Antigen tests are great for this. Moreover if you are negative with an antigen test, it likely means you are not infectious, even if still infected.
Figuring out where to get a Covid test, whether in the public or private health sector, should not involve a lengthy Internet search (which we did) or a doctor’s referral. It should be
Overpriced
The nurse at the drive-in site was kind enough to tell us about another obscure site which did not require a doctor’s referral. We managed to find it after asking several people. The antigen test cost R350. This is a standard retail price in South Africa. Yet the bulk wholesale price is R130 per test.
In Germany you can buy antigen tests for home-use for less than R20. In the UK they are distributed free. In India antigen tests are less than R50.
We are being charged far too much, and we have to go to far too much trouble to get tested.
Home-testing
Last week we reported that the regulator is opposed to home-testing even though this is now standard in the UK, US and other countries. Some doctors we’ve spoken to support it. Others are nervous about the quality of testing people will do at home, or whether people will report when they test positive.
Making tests affordable would allow much better detection of Covid at home, work and school. Even keeping track of positive tests on the national surveillance system could be as simple as sending a photograph of the test, and some basic information to a government number.
Home testing is already the norm for HIV or pregnancy and could easily become the norm for Covid-19.
At a minimum home-testing should be piloted, perhaps in a few towns or one or two cities to start.
No-fuss testing
But even if home testing isn’t adopted, anyone should be able to walk into any pharmacy or clinic, and quickly get an antigen test done, for much less than we’re currently paying.
Our staff member tested negative. It took a couple of hours to find this out, including a drive and quite a bit of money. If we had antigen tests in our office, we could have found out the result for much less money within a few minutes.
Next: Unemployed mothers and caregivers struggle to access Covid-19 grant
Previous: Immigrants in Gqeberha say they live in fear after Cele and Mbalula’s remarks
Letters
Dear Editor
I support your indignation at the need for a doctor's letter delaying testing. My experience today would discourage most people from persevering with a test.
I went to Lancet at Mediclinic Sandton and waited in the queue. when I reached the front, I was informed that I needed a doctor's letter. I was on my way home but I duly contacted the doctor who was kind enough to send me a letter via email.
I went back to Mediclinic Sandton and waited in the queue. As I reached the front they asked for the letter which I produced - then they asked whether it was a Lancet registered doctor (which I didn't know because they didn't tell me it needed to be)
So out of the queue again to contact the doctor - very fortunately she took my call quickly and confirmed they weren't.
So I'm out of the queue again need to find a Lancet registered doctor to send a letter for the test.
It's the dark days of Home Affairs - I cannot imagine what would happen to poorer people who do not have the resources to go back and forth. Never criticise the inefficiency of the public sector when the private sector elevates it to an art form and charges you for it.
© 2021 GroundUp. This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
You may republish this article, so long as you credit the authors and GroundUp, and do not change the text. Please include a link back to the original article.
We put an invisible pixel in the article so that we can count traffic to republishers. All analytics tools are solely on our servers. We do not give our logs to any third party. Logs are deleted after two weeks. We do not use any IP address identifying information except to count regional traffic. We are solely interested in counting hits, not tracking users. If you republish, please do not delete the invisible pixel.