9 April 2025
In 2013, the City of Cape Town relocated families to this temporary relocation area (TRA) in Gugulethu. Years later, the families are still there and say they’ve been forgotten. Photos: Mary-Anne Gontsana
Families who were moved to a temporary relocation area (TRA) in Gugulethu, Cape Town 12 years ago say they’ve been abandoned there, and fear that it has become their permanent home.
They were relocated to the TRA by the City of Cape Town because the dilapidated Masonwabe Hostel they were living in was demolished for being “dangerous and uninhabitable,” according to the City.
Situated behind the Gugulethu police station, it’s hard to miss the rows of white Masonwabe TRA structures within a fenced off area. When people were first relocated, about 80 families were housed at the TRA. Now there are about 136 structures, the City recently confirmed.
Andile Ngcwangu had moved there from the hostel. Inside, his home looks incomplete. There are exposed steel frames covered with what looks like a sheet for insulation and zinc. There’s a small bathroom inside with a toilet and sink.
Pointing out holes on the side of his home, Ngcwangu explains how he dodged bullets in February when rival gangs were shooting near the TRA.
He complained that the structures aren’t being maintained, forcing them to live in difficult conditions. “When it’s cold, the structures are cold inside and the same when it is hot, it becomes unbearable. The structures also have holes where mice come in,” he said.
Masonwabe community chairperson, Nolusindiso Leputhing, said they want the City to fulfil its promise that the TRAs would not be their permanent home. “It has been 12 years now and we are still here … Instead, the City is constructing roads here. Why are they making roads if we are only supposed to be here temporarily? It’s like they are now trying to fix this place because they know that we won’t be moving. There’s no communication,” said Leputhing.
Andile Ngcwangu had moved into his TRA structure from the Masonwabe hostel in 2013. Most residents say they were told these ‘incomplete’ units would only be for a short period.
She said some families grew since moving there in 2013 and no longer could fit into the small structures. “Some have resorted to extending their structures to make more space.”
“We need to know what is happening. What will happen to the old hostel site? Will they build houses for us there or not?” asked Leputhing.
When GroundUp reported on the Masonwabe hostel in 2013, Bruce Oom, former spokesman for the former Western Cape MEC for Human Settlements, Bonginkosi Madikizela said, “The structures are built so people would have somewhere to live while repairs are being carried out on the Masonwabe hostels in Gugulethu. The affected families are expected to move back to the hostel site when all restoration work is completed, and the houses most likely taken down. The houses currently are only for the residents of the hostels.”
But this month, the City told GroundUp that the “relocation of the residents is not in the City’s immediate plans”.
“TRAs are also known as incremental development areas and are parcels of land that have been developed for families in need of emergency housing, for as long as their emergency lasts,” said the City.
Asked what the City’s plan was for the now empty site of the Masonwabe hostel and whether houses would be built there, the City only responded saying it would “provide an update in due course.”